*Picture courtesy of The Indian Express. The Jharkhand High Court observed that recruitment rules cannot override the statutory protections guaranteed to persons with disabilities under the 2016 Act. (Image generated using AI)

When a woman with a locomotor disability missed a recruitment running-test deadline by just three seconds, she was excluded despite clearing the written examination. The Jharkhand High Court has now made an important distinction between treating everyone identically and ensuring that everyone gets a fair opportunity.

A RECRUITMENT TEST WITHOUT REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION

The case concerns Juthika Pal, a 38-year-old woman from Dumka, who applied for a chowkidar post under the Persons with Disabilities (PwD) category in the 2025 recruitment drive for 328 vacancies. Four per cent of the posts were reserved for persons with disabilities.

After clearing the written examination, she was required to take the same physical running test as other candidates, without additional time or any reasonable accommodation. She completed the run in 10 minutes and three seconds against the prescribed limit of 10 minutes and was disqualified.

ELEVEN RESERVED POSTS REMAINED VACANT

Of the 13 posts reserved for persons with disabilities, only two had been filled, leaving 11 vacant. Pal's representation seeking consideration for appointment remained pending, prompting her to approach the High Court.

The State argued that the recruitment rules and its 2018 notification did not provide for additional time or exemption from the physical test.

THE LAW MUST ENABLE EQUALITY

On 4 November, Justice Deepak Roshan held that the absence of specific provisions in recruitment rules could not override the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. Referring to Sections 2(y) and 20, and the Supreme Court's ruling in Vikash Kumar v. UPSC, the Court emphasised the State's obligation to provide reasonable accommodation.

It directed the Dumka authorities to take steps towards Pal's appointment and issue her appointment letter within eight weeks of receiving the order.

EQUALITY IS NOT ALWAYS ABOUT IDENTICAL RULES

True equality recognises different needs and removes barriers that prevent people from participating on fair terms. Reasonable accommodation is not preferential treatment; it is a legal safeguard that makes opportunity meaningful. The judgement is a reminder that recruitment systems must measure merit without overlooking the dignity and rights of persons with disabilities.

 

Source: https://indianexpress.com/article/legal-news/running-test-by-3-seconds-jharkhand-high-court-job-disabled-woman-10967773/ 

 

support jharkhand state news

If you value our journalism, consider making a voluntary contribution to help us continue bringing news, stories and information to our readers.

Scan the QR code to contribute

Support Jharkhand State News via UPI

Every contribution, big or small, is appreciated.

must read